[ home / overboard ] [ date ] [ soy / qa / raid / incel ] [ int / pol ] [ a / biz / fit / mtv / r9k / sude / tech / v / x ] [ q / news / chive / rules / pass / bans / status ] [ booru / wiki ]

A banner for soyjak.party

/soy/ - Soyjaks

soyjaks and other associated gems
Catalog
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Password (For file deletion.)

File: giga reader library.png 📥︎ (456.6 KB, 736x840) ImgOps

 №19038419[Quote]

Humanoid labor fails first principles.
A "working" humanoid is a fantasy that died after "miss Honeywell" in 1968. No humanoid has ever taken a job from a person, and it never will for the same reason. It's NOT a technical or AI problem, it's a "first principles" problem.

Think of it this way, Automation has been replacing people in factories for decades and it hasn't stopped. So if a humanoid can do it, it’s already automated because a humanoid IS only automation. So there are no jobs for humanoids in factories.

Or think of it this way, Just because you can put intelligence into a robot doesn't mean it has to be a humanoid. Therefore nobody waited for a humanoid to put intelligence into their machines and robots.

Or think of it this way, A humanoid uses state of the art technology in hardware and software(AI) and is meant to replace labor. Factory automation uses the same state of the art technology to replace labor. Improvements in technology apply to both, so FUTURE humanoids will never have a place in factories either. But improvements in AI will of course make improvements in automation.

See the problem?, You're trying to put a mechanical horse in front of a horseless carriage. It's like making a robo taxi by putting a humanoid in the driver seat. Maybe you can do it but you're adding cost, complexity and silliness.

"Physical AI" is not new. Dozens of automation companies have been replacing people with machines for decades, so why aren't they making humanoids? Do all of them lack foresight? Are they sitting around waiting for a humanoid to use their products? No! they have already incorporated AI into them! The "Physical AI" revolution has already been underway. There is nothing new happening except now the tech bros want mechanical slaves but don't realize they already have them. Smart automation already exists. "Physical AI" is just a new buzzword.

Warehouse and farming robots are not humanoid but they are smart. That's why Amazon is not replacing people with humanoids. It would be ridiculous for a humanoid to lay bricks or use human welding equipment. So "Path Robotics" and "Monumental" make non-humanoid robots to do it. Should a future robot electrician/plumber have built in power tools and cameras at the tools? Or is a humanoid going to carry hand tools around and stick its head under the sink to fix it?

BMW and Xiaomi are using humanoids but look at them! They're pitiful, a person would be fired for working so slow and they're not doing anything they need fingers for!?! In those applications a simple AMR would have far fewer parts/costs better reliability and performance than a mass produced complicated humanoid robot with a limited point-of-view and weak fingers instead of strong grippers. All it needs is the AI for such a simple task.

Many seem to think factory jobs are easy but a lousy housekeeper doesn’t cut it. It can't work at McDonalds because the hands can't open bags, make change, wash etc. Also it should be obvious that AI does not need a humanoid to replace someone working at a desk. But they would be really nice if a disabled person could use it as a telepresence to go shopping, do simple chores, etc. TAM will be small. There will be more AMR's than "working" humanoids.

"it's a humanoid so it can work in a human environment" A factory IS a "human environment"
The form or brains don’t matter. What matters is what it can do. They can be tour guides, toys, entertainers, criminals, supercharger tenders etc. Maybe it can be a lousy housekeeper/ caretaker but if it cooks and cleans, I'm not sure I would trust its hygiene.

Hot, heavy, dirty and dangerous jobs. There are hundreds of millions of them around the world. And if a humanoid could actually do it, LOL, without breaking or overheating, LOL, most of those jobs pay super low wages in places where there is no electricity to charge it anyway.

Hands are underestimated. They can wash themselves! a must for many jobs. They can sense pressure AND the direction of pressure on ALL surfaces. When you put a lid on a paper cup you don't crush it because your soft palm can feel the pressure around the lid. Soft fingertips can open a plastic bag, grasp and manipulate small parts without looking, feel slight imperfections, open a jar, handle money, scissors, screwdriver etc. etc.
Emulating a hand is impractical and unnecessary.

A "working" humanoid is really the antitheses of "first principles". If the goal is to emulate a human then you must make a humanoid/android. But if the goal is doing things that a human can do, then first principles DOES NOT dictate a humanoid! So AI is already "embodied" or "physical" because automation never waits for a humanoid. And if you do want to emulate a human you must choose the characteristics you want it to have so a one-size-fits-all like Optimus is not practical. It's groupthink nonsense


[Return][Catalog][Go to top][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / overboard ] [ date ] [ soy / qa / raid / incel ] [ int / pol ] [ a / biz / fit / mtv / r9k / sude / tech / v / x ] [ q / news / chive / rules / pass / bans / status ] [ booru / wiki ]