[ home / overboard ] [ date ] [ soy / qa / raid / incel ] [ int / pol ] [ a / biz / fit / mtv / r9k / sude / tech / v / x ] [ q / news / chive / rules / pass / bans / status ] [ booru / wiki ]

A banner for soyjak.party

/soy/ - Soyjaks

soyjaks and other associated gems
Catalog
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Password (For file deletion.)

File: 31310 - soybooru.com - 1so….png 📥︎ (294.53 KB, 1074x950) ImgOps

 â„–18939603[Quote]

LiberARYANS of /soy/, give me your best elevator pitch of Right-Libertarianism to an anarchocommunist (or at least someone in that general school of thought)

 â„–18939612[Quote]

marge i dont understand yhe question

 â„–18939622[Quote]

>>18939612
youre ESL

 â„–18939651[Quote]

>>18939622
im efl i just dont understand what you want

 â„–18939659[Quote]

>>18939651
I want you to give me an introductory argument for Right-Libertarian beliefs.

 â„–18939665[Quote]

File: 1791770233965m.png 📥︎ (1.04 MB, 800x800) ImgOps

>LiberARYANS of /soy/, give me your best elevator pitch of Right-Libertarianism to an anarchocommunist (or at least someone in that general school of thought)

 â„–18939693[Quote]

Imagine everything you got was from a subscription from a company instead of the community

 â„–18939906[Quote]

I think right-libertarianism is stupid but maybe you could form an argument on the basis of how a society based on a free market and voluntary association is ideal for ensuring that people (including the working class) have a meaningful way to choose what they do with their lives instead of being bled to death by taxes demanded by the state (which has always been a vehicle for monopolies to consolidate themselves and undermine their competition by means of regulation)
But ultimately the best argument against anarchocommunists is time because if they aren't retarded they'll eventually grow out of their childish belief-system

 â„–18939925[Quote]

>>18939906
What system do you advocate for?

 â„–18939955[Quote]

>>18939603 (OP)
It supports trans rights

 â„–18940011[Quote]

>>18939925
I'm center-left, I think I would want a system close to that of fascist Italy

 â„–18940013[Quote]

>>18939906
I am sadly very retarded, so don't hold your breath.

 â„–18940043[Quote]

I cant argument against anarcho communism because it is inherently impossible by definition. I can tell you why it is stupid. For a moneyless, stateless, classless society to emerge, there has to be an entity which doesnt permit states, money, classes and that redistributes wealth. For it to have this large of a control over soyciety it has to be a huge authoritarian government. How can you enforce these rules without a state?

 â„–18940048[Quote]

OP is a reddit troon DNI

 â„–18940053[Quote]

>>18940048
Most of us are reddit troons nigga

 â„–18940075[Quote]

>>18940053
Marge…

 â„–18940081[Quote]

>>18940075
Have you seen the catty recently?

 â„–18940092[Quote]

>>18939906
I think the best argument is just decentralization. Why would you have a central government having control over everything when you can have various small entities competing with each other? There is close to no incentive to produce anything in the state controlled world.

 â„–18940099[Quote]

>>18940081
It's just bait nusoi or however the problem is swept under the rug

 â„–18940106[Quote]

go on /pol/ or larty they'll help u

 â„–18940134[Quote]

>>18940106
Larty is a dnb nigga. It was raided by the swinny in the first few days

 â„–18940183[Quote]

>>18940092
That might be a decent argument against regular communists but it's not going to help against left-wing anarchists who already believe in decentralization
Also there are many easy rebuttals against this, like the reality being that 'various small entities' are rarely able to achieve anything on their own and will be dependent on each other, a lot of the time the way they choose to compete actually limits them, like when they can't agree on a standard that would allow greater interoperability.
Similarly, part of New York City's infrastructure is private, or something like that, and so whenever a company needs to install new cables they have to get workers to dig up the ground and poke around to install their own next to the existing ones, instead of sharing. That's why there is always roadwork being done and always part of the street blocked off, because it's not coherent



[Return][Catalog][Go to top][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / overboard ] [ date ] [ soy / qa / raid / incel ] [ int / pol ] [ a / biz / fit / mtv / r9k / sude / tech / v / x ] [ q / news / chive / rules / pass / bans / status ] [ booru / wiki ]