[ home / overboard ] [ soy / qa / raid / r ] [ craft ] [ int / pol ] [ a / an / asp / biz / mtv / r9k / tech / v / sude / x ] [ q / news / chive / rules / pass / bans / status ] [ wiki / booru / irc ]

A banner for soyjak.party

/pol/ - International /Pol/itics & /Bant/er

Politics & countrywars
Catalog
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Flag
File
Password (For file deletion.)

File: 1771299830462w.png 📥︎ (20.4 KB, 450x563) ImgOps

 â„–2897163[Quote]

How do non-religious polbros justify universal morality, if you believe in it?
Why should you care for a weaker being's suffering?

 â„–2897173[Quote]

>>2897163 (OP)
it's scientifically proven. toddlers are empathetic towards other and even inanimate objects like plushies

 â„–2897180[Quote]

>>2897163 (OP)
Just be a decent human being lol, but really you shouldn't do whatever you want with other people because it sets a bad precedent, not really a universal morality but just common decency.

 â„–2897183[Quote]

>>2897173
They're dumb

 â„–2897192[Quote]

>>2897173
this doesn't proves universal morality

 â„–2897205[Quote]

>>2897183
i justify it because of my inner urge to be heckin wholesome
>>2897192
how does it not? they are not conditioned in any way, it's their instinct to help others

 â„–2897208[Quote]

From an evolutionary standpoint there are actually a lot of potential explanations for it, but setting those aside it also seems to be a natural result of higher intelligence. Whales will protect smaller animals from predators, rats will consistently choose to save a trapped cagemate over food, there's a wide variety of accounts of intelligent animals displaying what certainly seems like empathy. At a certain level of awareness it seems like animals become able to imagine what it would be like if they were the ones suffering, and a lot of them seemingly choose to act on it

 â„–2897210[Quote]

>>2897205
Other pipo are not so wholesome…

 â„–2897212[Quote]

>>2897205
rarely some toddlers arent though

 â„–2897219[Quote]

>>2897173
>>2897208
But this doesn't justify it. It's just a feeling, no different from any other.

 â„–2897222[Quote]

>>2897208
In regards to the whale, I believe it's more out of spite then anything, if I'm not wrong things like Orcas tend to attack baby whales, so of course adult whales would want to fuck with them, they don't give a shit about who they're protecting really, as for the rat… That's just kin, two rats can probably work together and find more food then just taking the food that's in front of them, and if you think intelligence = empathy, dolphins.

 â„–2897234[Quote]

because you don't want to suffer, that's about it

 â„–2897242[Quote]

the OP should differentiate between morality that is objectively beneficious (eg. helping others in distress) and morality that only gives the guidelines to organizing social life (eg. sexuality), though
>>2897219
it's justified from the evolutionary standpoint, as it guarantees survival of the species without permanently straining the ones who are helping

 â„–2897243[Quote]

>>2897219
>>2897222
My point was moreso that it doesn't seem to be limited to just us, there's probably some underlying threshold for it, and if it weren't beneficial in the long run evolution would have nuked it by now. I should clarify that in my comments about intelligence, I was moreso referring to animals that are very social to begin with.

And yeah, dolphins are a VERY notable exception, I'm all too familiar with the shit they get up to.

 â„–2897251[Quote]

>>2897243
You're not wrong, empathy (among the species) just improves social cohesion and cooperation in general, I don't think anyone is arguing against that, but yes out group empathy has proven evolutionary purpose, we wouldn't be here if it wasn't for all the wholesome animalrinnos that we domesticated and still feel for.

 â„–2897255[Quote]

>>2897243
Also yeah Dolphins are the niggers of the ocean

 â„–2897267[Quote]

btw this is Alunyafag

 â„–2897271[Quote]

>>2897267
Fine by me, I actually don't mind talking with them all things considered

 â„–2897284[Quote]

>>2897271
if you don't mind wasting your time

 â„–2897288[Quote]

>>2897284
The conversations they spark are usually interesting at least

 â„–2897293[Quote]

>>2897284
Buck broken by AlunyaGOD

 â„–2897321[Quote]

>>2897288
they are, if you're falling for the obvious logical fallacies he's making. it's a game of getting close enough to the truth, but far enough to farm a response.

 â„–2897342[Quote]

File: Hunter.PNG 📥︎ (1.28 MB, 1432x1853) ImgOps

Empathy for others coupled with instincts of self-preservation undergird support for a system of conflict resolution and avoidance.

 â„–2897347[Quote]

>>2897342
You're the last person I'd talk philosophy with, go away

 â„–2897363[Quote]

File: Lavender.PNG 📥︎ (1.12 MB, 1000x1725) ImgOps

>>2897347
Erm why?

 â„–2897376[Quote]

>>2897219
there's basically no other reason to do anything other than "it feels right" though, i mean that's why we've developed emotions in the first place, so feelings actually perfectly justify morality

 â„–2897388[Quote]

>>2897363
You're intellectually shallow and my gegbvll

 â„–2897396[Quote]

File: Tulip.PNG 📥︎ (739.5 KB, 1000x1839) ImgOps

>>2897388
How so?

 â„–2897402[Quote]

>>2897163 (OP)
This isn't a real thing
Take your meds

 â„–2897403[Quote]


 â„–2897412[Quote]

>>2897396
You're an African-American, not known for their brains

 â„–2897415[Quote]

File: Lilac.PNG 📥︎ (809.08 KB, 1000x1753) ImgOps

>>2897412
I'm not however.

 â„–2897425[Quote]

>>2897415
We've had this argument many times and you always fail to substantiate enough proof, in the contrary, I absolutely buck break you with snopes fact checked evidence.

 â„–2897437[Quote]

All humans believe in the supernatural by some extent.

 â„–2897448[Quote]

File: FN Herstal.PNG 📥︎ (1.03 MB, 1489x1781) ImgOps

>>2897425
You took issue with my sympathy for black separatism. I don't remember much else.

 â„–2897460[Quote]

Monkey strong together.
Monkey cannot be together if monkey attack monkey.
Therefore, monkey set boundaries so no attack each other.
Not universal but if enough monkey agree it's good enough.

 â„–2897470[Quote]

>>2897347
he has double ur intellect you dumb nigger

 â„–2897473[Quote]

why macaco angry? macaco happy



[Return][Catalog][Go to top][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[ home / overboard ] [ soy / qa / raid / r ] [ craft ] [ int / pol ] [ a / an / asp / biz / mtv / r9k / tech / v / sude / x ] [ q / news / chive / rules / pass / bans / status ] [ wiki / booru / irc ]